Prepaid travel cards have become highly popular over the last 12 months and are fast becoming one of the preferred payment methods for British tourists while travelling abroad. Prepaid cards provide travellers with additional security measures compared to cash and traditional credit or debit cards, and are available in many currencies.
These advantages over more traditional methods of payment have seen the number of prepaid travel cards soar, but are UK tourists paying more money for the privilege of using one? Prepaid cards do often incur fees and charges for withdrawing cash at ATMs and making purchases, particularly when used in the UK, but is this all consumers are paying for?
Prepaid currency cards are available here in the UK in a wide variety of foreign currencies, allowing consumers to travel the world with little worry about accessing their money. The most common prepaid travel cards are those available in the Euro and US Dollar but there are cards which cater for less popular currencies too, such as the South African Rand and the New Zealand Dollar.
Prepaid card exchange rates
Prepaid card exchange rates can vary greatly depending on the card provider but we will use a few of the most popular cards as an example.
Travelex claims to “check the exchange rates of the major banks and high street retailers to ensure we give you the best overall price on your foreign currency – or we refund the difference – that’s the Travelex online promise”.
However, it seems that this promise does not apply to its prepaid card exchange rates because it doesn’t apply to services offered in conjunction with a partner company, when orders are placed on the cashpassport.com website or when a Cash Passport card is being reloaded.
Despite this difference, by following the steps on the Travelex website I can purchase €570 as cash or on a new prepaid card for £516.30 – making the exchange rate for both 1 GBP = 1.104 EUR.
The CaxtonFX Europe Traveller prepaid currency card has been voted the holidaymakers’ favourite card but does it live up to expectations when you compare exchange rates? CaxtonFX proudly displays its exchange rates on the homepage of its website, with today being 1 GBP = 1.1100 EUR, turning £516.30 into €573.09.
The Virgin Prepaid Travel Card is a Visa card available in Euros and US Dollars. While Virgin doesn’t make any claims about guaranteeing the best exchange rate, it does claim to be competitive. The website allows you to view the exchange rates when you apply for the card, which were 1 GBP = 1.0730 EUR, turning £516.30 into €553.99 – clearly the worst value for money out of our top three prepaid currency cards.
Other exchange rates
Before prepaid travel cards came about, most UK tourists visited the bank, travel agent or Post Office to buy foreign currency and traveller’s cheques before going on holiday. Are these places now able to offer the ‘competitive’ exchange rates that they boast? Consumer Focus doesn’t think so, and it has managed to persuade the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) to investigate the hidden charges involved in buying currency.
Mike O’Connor, chief executive at Consumer Focus, said: “Converting £500 into euros can cost from less than £10 to more than £30 depending on where you switch your money. This is a huge difference for essentially providing the same service and, typically, banks offer the worst deal.”
Sainsbury’s Bank, which offers currency exchange in the larger Sainsbury’s stores as a convenience to customers who wish to do their shopping and pick up their Travel Money is currently offering an exchange rate of 1 GBP = 1.1041 EUR, offering me €570.05 for £516.30, €3.04 less than the CaxtonFX Prepaid Card.
The trusty Post Office, winner of Best Foreign Exchange/Travel Money Retailer at the British Travel Awards 2010, is able to offer holidaymakers €569.94 for £516.30 cash today at an exchange rate of 1 GBP = 1.1039 EUR, which is €3.15 less than the CaxtonFX card.
Perhaps HSBC ‘the world’s local bank’ will be able to prove the chief executive of Consumer Focus wrong. Using the website’s currency calculator it was found that £516.30 would buy UK holidaymakers just €550.50, with the exchange rate sitting at 1GBP = 1.0662 EUR. This result is the worst overall, achieving €22.59 less than the best option, the CaxtonFX Prepaid Card.
Let’s see how that all looks in a table (Exchange rates correct at time of writing at 10am on 28th October 2011):
Prepaid travel cards prevail
We have found that, in general, prepaid card exchange rates are very competitive compared to the other options on the foreign currency market, although there are some which don’t offer the same great rates as others. In order to ensure that you get the best value for money when travelling abroad, check out a wide variety of sources for your foreign currency.
Although prepaid travel cards are a modern alternative to more traditional payment methods there is no need to be sceptical about their rates. These prepaid currency cards are accepted at millions of locations worldwide, and they do offer so many benefits which you cannot find with cash and traveller’s cheques.





